Clue: A Curious Cornucopia of Conclusions

In Clue (1985), based on the board game of the same name, a colorful assortment of bumbling and secretive government workers in the middle of the Cold War era get mysteriously invited to dine at a secluded mansion, with murder, hijinks and lots of chaotic running around to ensue. The movie spawned many notable quotes and is a standout of the cinematic parody genre, turning a murder mystery into a comedic farce where the bodies pile up without much investigation. However, one of the most unique parts of the movie is also what hurt it at the box office.

Clue was released with three endings, each revealing a different killer. Endings A and B give singular culprits, while Ending C, which is labeled as the “true ending,” turns the insanity up to a maximum, with almost every guest having killed someone–a very unexpected twist. When the film was playing in theaters, the filmmakers decided to split the endings up between screenings. At every movie theater, one ending was selected at random to play as the only ending shown at that theater. Later, all three endings were compiled and played one after the other in home video and streaming releases of the movie. These different endings then caused a lot of confusion for audiences and contributed to many negative reviews of the movie when it was first released.

There is a good reason for that confusion: Clue doesn’t work as well as it does without all three endings to bookend it. The movie’s way of parodying the murder mystery genre is by removing the aspect of certainty from it. Classic murder mysteries follow a typical formula: a large cast, a genius detective, obvious red herrings and most importantly, the definitive grand reveal of the killer at the end. Despite each investigation turning out differently with different tropes and characters, there is a comfort in knowing that everything will be wrapped up neatly by the last scene.

Clue laughs in the face of this certainty. There is no detective among the houseguests; the closest we get to a central deductive figure is Tim Curry’s Wadsworth, the nosy butler who is just as much of a hapless participant and suspect as the other characters. Very little time is spent trying to discover clues, with more focus on hilarious verbal misunderstandings between the guests and hiding the growing number of corpses from outsiders who keep showing up at the mansion doors. Instead of being mostly dramatic and tight-lipped, the characters are over-the-top and spend most of their time “investigating” by running around while loudly exclaiming their fears, tampering with what could be legitimate evidence and participating in loads of sexual innuendo. 

The endings, when watched all together, are the climax of this zany ride. It caps off the breakneck and flailing tone of the movie by having viewers watch Wadsworth run around explaining the solution three different times, each time using different clues to explain the different true culprits. Most importantly, the different endings upend the most important scene of any murder mystery: the definitive reveal. The audience is simultaneously given three reveals and no definitive answer, as every ending–even the “true” one as designated by a blatant title card–has random leaps in logic. The progression from Ending A to C both escalates the ridiculousness to a maximum while still ending in a satisfying way. The point is that there is no definitive killer, as the movie is about lampooning a murder mystery formula rather than actually fulfilling it.

Watching only one ending, like audiences did in the initial theatrical release, feels unsatisfying because the previously zany and all-over-the-place plot wraps up with a decently conventional ending. Furthermore, getting either Endings A or B make the ending too generic and without the ridiculous final twists of Ending C gives. For a movie that smashes every other major trope of the genre it parodies, a single conclusive ending doesn’t fit with the rest of it at all.


Ultimately, these three endings provide the capstone to Clue’s witty parody of a usually conventional and predictable genre. The movie maintains its consistent comedic genius with these endings and takes a hammer (or rather a lead pipe) to the ultimate trope of the murder mystery. Give it a watch this dreary cold season as the solution(s) to liven up a dark and stormy day. 


Popular Reviews



More in Comedy Reviews

Next
Next

The Boy and the Heron: Choosing Reality over Fantasy